Comparative_analysis_of_the_fltron_and_biosand_water_filterseditms.pdf
William F. Duke, MD,1* Rick Nordin2 and Asit Mazumder2
1University of Victoria, Restoration of Natural Systems Program , Victoria, British Columbia,
2University of Victoria, Department of Biology, P.O. Box 3020 STN CSC, Victoria, British Columbia
* Corresponding author;
Abstract
For many of the 1.1 billion people who now lack access to safe water, affordable water filters designed for use in individual households provide a practical alternative to municipal water treatment systems. Two of the most commonly promoted filters in developing countries are the Filtron ceramic filter and the BioSand intermittent slow sand filter.
To compare the performance of these two filters, pond water was put through each filter for 30 consecutive days. Turbidity, TOC, DOC, E. coli and total coliform counts were recorded daily for the source water and for the filtered water from each filter. Flow rates and frequency of cleaning were also recorded for each filter. Both filters lowered the turbidity, TOC, DOC, and bacterial counts significantly.
The Filtron filter was more effective in removing bacteria, but it was limited by flow rates of only 1-2 liters per hour as well as the need for frequent cleaning. The biosand filter produced flow rates of about 20 liters per hour and did not require cleaning during the study period, but it was less effective in removing bacteria.