Arsenic removal for ceramic water filters

Journal of
Humanitarian
Engineering
Volume 1, Issue 1 – May 2012
ISSN 2200-4904

 

Mishant Kumar
Faculty of Engineering, University of Technology, Sydney, Australia
Mishant.S.Kumar@gmail.com

ABSTRACT: Arsenic in drinking water is a hazard to human health and is a known carcinogen
(Mass 1992). Resource Development International – Cambodia (RDIC) has researched, developed,
and manufactured simple ceramic water filters (CWF) which have proved to be extremely effective
in removing pathogens from water. These filters however, do not remove arsenic from water, which
exists in the source water at levels above the World Health Organisation (WHO) guideline of 10μg/L.
The aims of this literature based study were to investigate conventional and non-conventional
arsenic removal processes, and to discuss the options for applying an arsenic removal technology
to the CWFs produced by RDIC. It was found that conventional arsenic removal technologies are
difficult to implement in the context of household water treatment in a developing country. This
study suggested that non-conventional arsenic removal technologies shall be more effective and
that field studies must be undertaken to verify the success of such methods.

Ceramic, filter, arsenic, removal, household.

Download (PDF, 5.41MB)

The Difficulty of Improving Simplicity – Ceramic Water Purifier

Rudimentary Ceramic Water Purifier (CWFs) were originally manufactured by hand with the same basic materials used in current models. These filters were hand formed from a mixture of minimally processed local clay combined with a burnout material such as pine sawdust or dung. Efforts by early CWF technicians Ron Rivera, and Fernando Mazariegos working with the Asociacion Guatemalteca para la Familia de las Americas (AFA) led to the development of a more consistent form by lining a metal pail with plastic and forming the filter on the inside surface.

During this time the large scale filter industry was already manufacturing micro-porus ceramic filters treated with colloidal silver. These filters used diatomaceous earth in place of sawdust, and were formed as “candle” type filters, small cylinders adopting plastic housing and mounting systems. Although this compact format resolved issues of transport, the complex assembly coupled with leakage problems made their local manufacture and adoption unreasonable.

As the basic qualities of an effective filter were being examined it was realized that in order for the filter to produce reliable results, issues regarding consistency of form would have to be addressed. Adaptable forms were already being produced in the low-fired ceramic flower pot industry. Mass produced terra cotta flower pots are being manufactured in India, China, and Italy using electric over hydraulic presses and aluminum molds. It was decided to re-produce these production methods in a more appropriate manner for localities with very basic infrastructure. The first CWF presses to utilize aluminum molds and hand operated hydraulic jacks were made in Central America.

As the technology continues to develop the primary challenge continues to be: how do we improve on the manufacturing process by making it more simple? Certainly industry is familiar with the challenge of producing a better product by adding layers of expensive and complex technology.The challenge in our case is to keep the manufacturing locally sourced and accessible to areas lacking basic utilities. To that end significant effort is being made towards improvements in basic equipment and manufacturing best practices. The greatest achievements in CWF technology will involve batch consistency and simple ways to improve the three primary objectives: Flow rate, Filter strength, and Bacterial removal efficiency.

http://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fernando_Mazariegos

Problems with Mold Release

Ceramic water filters are typically cast-formed utilizing aluminum, steel or sometimes concrete molds. The wet mix or charge is placed in or over the molds and the male and female are forced together under pressure to form the shape. Two plastic bags on the inside and outside of the form act as separators that allow the new filter to be easily and cleanly released from the molds. Since developing the process, and in collaboration with filter producers, we have sought an alternative to the use of plastic bags. Attempts have been made to replace bags by using:

  • palm oil
  • teflon
  • waste oil
  • silicone spray
  • silicone plastic

A Ghanaian filter producer (Tamakloe Ceramics) reportedly has been able to eliminate one of the bags by carefully applying palm oil to the inside of the female mold before each pressing.

An Italian flower pot manufacturer reportedly using a thin liquid as a release agent utilizing a similar twin mold technology.

The Ram Company utilizes plaster press molding techniques in which forms are ejected from porous hydraulic plaster by employing compressed air. While this technology would work, it would require an on going supply of hydraulic plaster. 

Material input variables

Fine Vs. Coarse sawdust
What is the relationship between fine and coarse sawdust on filter strength?

 

1. Compare filters of gradually increasing amounts of fine, and then coarse, sawdust. Compare strength of filters of similar flow rate.
2. Refire low flow rate filters to attempt to equalize the flow rates, then Compare strength of filters of similar flow rate. (Hypothesis is that firing for longer, or higher, will increase both strength and flow rate).
3. If filters using fine sawdust and longer/higher firing results in a stronger filter of higher flow rate, compare fine sawdust filters with coarse sawdust filters of the same flow rate for bacterial effectivity.

 

Adding Coarse Sand
What are the effects of coarse sand on a constant mix of clay and sawdust in terms of:
a) Strength
b) Flow rate
c) Bacterial effectivity
d) Shrinkage

Adding Crushed Filter Medium (Grog)
What are the effects of crushed filter grog  in a constant mix of clay and sawdust in terms of:
a) Strength
b) Flow rate
c) Bacterial effectivity
d) Shrinkage

Pugged Vs. Unpugged Clay
What is the effect of pugging clay  in addition to mechanical mixing on the  strength of ceramic water filters.
To evaluate this it is necessary to first agree on the method of evaluation. It is suggested that the filter strength be evaluated using a modified modulus of rupture test(MOR)

1. Compare constant mixes of filter medium with variable pugging times for strength and flow rate.

Development of appropriate mixers

Developing appropriate processing mixers, pug mills , or hybrid machines for ceramic water filter factories.

Ceramic pot filters that produce potable water are made from a mixture of clay and combustible materials, usually sawdust or rice husk. Both the clay and the combustible are crushed and screened, dry blended, and then wet mixed before forming. Factories employ simple paddle mixers and in some cases also, pug mills to prepare the mix. There are also factories which do the entire mixing process by hand. While it is possible to produce filters using a variety of methods it is useful to identify methods which produce better and consistent filters so that improvements can be made.

  • Paddle mixers are commonly used in filter factories but work best when the size of charge which they are mixing  is carefully monitored, neither too small or large. Too small a charge and the mixing action  will not work, too large and the mixer will also perform poorly. This is one reason why employing a pug mill after mixing can greatly increase the quality of the blending.
  • Pug mills do a fairly consistent job at wet blending materials. Pug mills are horizontal (most commonly) augers, that differ from paddle mixers in that they must be attended by an operator. The operator puts clay materials in the hopper where it is shredded and then compacted as it makes its way out the narrowing nozzle.  Performance and speed differ depending on size and whether the machine has  single or double screws. Pug mills come in either non-de airing or de-airing. De-airing is not necessary for filter mixes.
  • Hybrid pugger/ mixers

 

http://www.peterpugger.com/pugmill-extruder/pm-50-pugmill.html Commonly called Peter puggers, these are another potentially useful machines for filter blends. The machine integrates

the work of two machines, a mixer and a standard pug mill.
A hopper is loaded with the mix  and the machine  mixes and pugs,  depending in which direction the mixer is rotated. These machines do an excellent job integrating materials. The challenge with these machines is that they are expensive and tend to be beyond the reach of factories. Ideally an open-source version of this machine  might  be developed which would allow it to be produced locally at a reduced cost.

Use of concrete for mixer / puggers

Concrete Mixers were  first developed by Paul Soldner. http://www.soldnerequipment.com/index.html

This is a paddle type mixer where the body of the mixer is made with a rotating concrete hopper  and a fixed paddle.

In his book “A Potters Alternative”  Harry Davis outlines instructions and plans for making pugmills from both steel and concrete.  The concrete version would  be a potential model for filter workshops. By following the plans in the book perhaps a set of templates could be produced and made available to factories that wish to have machines produced locally. This robust design has great application for developing world factories because of its simplicity of design and because the machine is made with off the shelf parts (Dayton). Aside from the cast formed ferro-concrete drum there are no specialized parts on the machine  which make it an ideal candidate for open-source cloning. (http://www.axner.com/potters-alternative.aspx)


Affordable presence absence testing

Fired filters are currently being assessed by factories using three tests. Filters are
dunk tested to identify cracks that allow water to leak through the filter more quickly. If
they pass that test they are then soaked and flow tested. After flow testing, water from
some filters may be challenge tested to see if they actually remove bacteria. The cost of the
presence/absence (P/A) tests is prohibitive enough that not all filters are challenge
tested in this way.

Ideally every filter would be tested so that they are demonstrably capable of delivering
safe water. A simple P/A  test on the order of 10-40 cents each would make it cost
effective for producers to test every sound filter. This test would be conducted
at the same time that flow testing is conducted, allowing the producer to save
time and guarantee that each filter is demonstrably effective.

Batch Consistency – Ceramic Pot Water Filters

At Potters Without Borders our focus is on the transfer of skills required to manufacture strong, effective ceramic pot water filters. Manufacturing filters as an appropriate technology requires the utilization of locally sourced skills and raw materials. For technicians, the main challenge is to go through the process required to develop a working filter body within a short time, using greatly variable materials. Although these materials may differ between factories, it is very important to maintain batch consistency when selecting materials for what is essentially a health product.

Establishing a reliable mixture of clay, burnouts, and accessory materials requires a period of testing and troubleshooting. Although working mixtures have been established in other factory locations, the information gained from these experiments only give us a general idea of where to start. It is not only necessary to begin factory production with a lengthy testing period, but every time a new batch of raw materials comes into the factory, testing must be done to make sure they are of consistent source and quality.

Developing a system of record-keeping and filter numbering is a critical aspect of manufacture troubleshooting. Factories that have been in production for years discover, suddenly, peculiar changes in filter functioning or appearance. By going back through the logs we can discover if the change occured because of a change of material sourcing, or a firing schedule fluctuation.

When selecting a source of raw materials, one must consider that it is a finite resource. A feasability study attempts to identify problems of inconsistant availablilty, contaminated sources, or insufficient material for the lifetime of the factory. The variable nature of naturally sourced materials makes it impossible to produce an identical product every time, but following certain procedures allows us to produce a greater number of filters which fall within the range of acceptability.

Production protocols which have been extablished in the first months of setup should be recorded and maintained. Any improvements, or changes to manufacturing procedures must be recorded and re-produced through several operating cycles in order to be proven.

Finally, we must realize that producing a homogenous filter is beyond the scope of appropriate technology as it applies to these filters. What we want is to produce an effective filter as simply as possible with locally sourced materials and abilities. Consistency in materials, sourcing, and testing increases the percentage of effective filters in each production cycle.

La financiación de fábricas existentes

Las organizaciones que desean efectuar cambios positivos en la salud debido a enfermedades transmitidas por el agua, a menudo consideran que los sistemas de tratamiento llamados punto de utilización (POU) son los más efectivos en las comunidades rurales.

Estas organizaciones trabajan a nivel local o internacional en otros aspectos de asistencia, incluyendo salud, educación y ayuda a niños. Una vez concluida la investigación básica sobre la tecnología de filtros de cerámica para agua (CWF), los administradores deben tomar la decisión de o bien empezar de cero una nueva empresa de fabricación de filtros o bien invertir en un proyecto existente.

A los pequeños grupos que trabajan en específicas zonas objetivo se les recomienda en un principio que consideren la compra de un lote de filtros en la fábrica disponible más cercana. Esto sirve, por un lado, para determinar el interés local sobre el producto, y a la vez es una forma de impulsar las ventas de las fábricas existentes. Puede ocurrir que la solución definitiva para ambas partes se base en acuerdos de compra.

Otra de las ventajas de empezar con la importación de filtros a pequeña escala es que los grupos que buscan inversores en una empresa social pueden representar esta primera distribución como un primer estudio de mercado. El hecho de tener filtros a mano permite un excelente trato a las presentaciones, dando a los participantes un enfoque a las cuestiones de aplicación local.

Las organizaciones más grandes que consideren invertir en fábricas de filtros de cerámica deberían analizar el impacto del desarrollo de nuevas fábricas frente al apoyo a las facilidades ya existentes. Al estudiar el registro de creación de fábricas observamos la tendencia a la creación de nuevas fábricas que logran sus objetivos de inversión para producciones preliminares sólo para cumplir con la nueva lucha de metas de producción sostenibles. Los presupuestos para nuevas fábricas rara vez toman en consideración los costos a largo plazo para el desarrollo de un mercado estable.

Aunque la inversión inicial es importante al empezar la producción, el coste del dólar por dólar de la producción de filtros es menor cuando se invierte en unas instalaciones de producción ya facilitadas. Estas nuevas fábricas empiezan su producción con la más simple tecnología y el diseño de filtros más básico para entrar en el mercado. Con un impulso financiero secundario para mejorar la producción de la fábrica o desarrollar un plan de marketing más robusto, podríamos observar una ampliación de la distribución de filtros.

MSABI Clay Filter Pots – Removal of iron and manganese from groundwater sources

Iron and Manganese are naturally occurring metals commonly found in both surface water and groundwater.

In January 2012, MSABI determined that a review of possible methods for the removal of iron and manganese from source water should be undertaken. It is important to note that, in accordance with WHO guidelines, in most naturally occurring concentrations (including the levels measured to date in the Kilombero District), iron and manganese do not pose a health risk in terms of human consumption. In point of fact, both iron and manganese are important elements for human consumption and are dietary requirements.

However, the general Kilombero community is largely unaware of this fact, and there is (anecdotally speaking) a broad suspicion of and aversion to the presence of iron and manganese in both potable and non-potable water sources. Water with high iron and manganese content is aesthetically less desirable, as it is likely to have a metallic taste if used for potable consumption, and may cause light brown staining if used for washing or other similar purposes.

Because MSABI water points access aquifers at depths of up to 30 metres below ground level (reaching into and sometimes through rock deposits), relatively high concentrations of iron and manganese are more likely to exist in MSABI water.

In February 2012, a relevant example relating to community perceptions of safe and unsafe drinking water with respect to the presence of iron and manganese was presented to the MSABI lab.

Excerpt from: Iron Removal Summary

Maji Safa kwa Afya Bora Ifakara Website

Funding existing factories – Ceramic Pot Water Filters

Organizations seeking to effect positive change in health due to water borne disease often consider Point Of Use (POU) treatment systems to be the most effective method to reach rural communities.

These organizations work locally, or internationally in various other aspects of assistance including health, education, and childrens aid. Once basic research into Ceramic Pot Water Filter (CWF) technology has been done administrators are faced with the decision of weather to start a completely new filter manufacturing enterprise, or invest in an existing project.

Small groups working in a specifically target area are first recommended to consider purchasing a batch of filters from the closest manufacturer available. This is both a reliable way to determine local interest in the product, and also a way to bolster sales for existing factories. Its possible that sustained purchase agreements can be the ultimate solution for both parties.

Another benefit of beginning with small scale importation of filters is that groups seeking investors in a social enterprise can represent this primary distribution as primary market research. Having working filters in-hand lends a great deal to presentations, giving participants a focus to questions of local applicability.

Larger organizations considering investment in CWF factories would do well to examine the impact of developing new enterprises vs. support to existing facilities. When studying the track record of factory start-ups one sees the trend of new factories acchieving target investments for preliminary production, only to meet the new struggle of sustainable production targets. Budgets for new factories rarely take into consideration the long term costs of developing a stable market.

Although the initial investment to begin production is important, the dollar for dollar cost of producing filters is lower when investing in an already producing facility. These new factories begin production with the simplest form of technology, and the most basic of filter designs to put on the market. With a secondary financial boost to upgrade factory production, or to develop more robust marketing plans, we could see a scaling-up of filter distribution.

 

Letter from the president 2012

 

Six years ago I and a small group of individuals founded a Non-Profit organization which has the primary goal of expanding access to clean drinking water around the world. We do this specifically by fostering the development of all aspects of ceramic pot water filter technology. Our organization collects and disseminates information and resources from technical consultants, academics, funding organizations, and filter producers.

          We have become well established in the international filter community as facilitators of filter manufacturing and development. Through our relationship with the US based charity Potters For Peace, and the creation of the Joint Ceramic Filter Committee, we have developed a broad network of contacts which continues to grow and, true to our goal, we are helping put more ceramic water filters in the hands of the people.

We built this organization knowing that financial aid and technical assistance must be appropriately administered. The organization itself is supported by membership dues and donations, and is run completely by volunteers. We distribute factory development information for free. Plans for equipment, procedures for testing, reference material, and international contacts are written and distributed with an open-source philosophy. Membership dues and donations are distributed wisely by the Potters Without Borders Board of Directors among several annual projects, mostly pertaining to transportation and equipment, and minimally on things like printing, and website hosting.

           When requested, Potters Without Borders connects development groups with paid technical consultants who travel overseas to do hands-on training, feasibility studies and factory building. These consultants all sit on the Joint Filter Committee and work together to provide comprehensive responses to these requests.


As we get ready for the Potters Without Borders annual general meeting, I thought I would take this chance to inform you of our activities. 2012 promises to be another active year for Ceramic Water Filter development.

 

International Factory Implementations:

In 2011, we participated in the implementation of a factory in Guayaquil, Ecuador, partnering with Hogar De Christo (HOC), Engineers Without Borders, International Rotary Clubs, and Clarkson University. This factory is continuing to develop stable production of filters for market, and is exploring their distribution with HOC affordable housing projects. The next step here will be to complete construction of their kiln, and work on the distribution plan.

Kenya – In  assistance to  the UNICEF Kenya program, we conducted an evaluation of ceramic water filter production; making recommendations for the expansion of the technology in at risk areas of the country.

Ethiopia – We are working as technical advisers to the 7th Day Adventist Hospital at Gimbi, after having completed a feasibility study in the western area of the country. The hospital identified water borne diseases as the principle factor affecting their patients.They are anticipating developing filter production on the hospital grounds which would potentially assist the entire region. This project is seeking matching funding from prospective partners.

Rwanda – We assisted a ceramic cooperative in Kigali with training to start production in 2010. They are now looking for assistance to stabilize production and further advertising and marketing. We have been discussing a plan with UNICEF for a short term consultancy which would fund a six month position at the factory.

Plans are underway for upgrading production in eastern Africa, in concert with organizations like the German Red Cross, Red Crescent societies, and UNICEF. This year we are assisting in factory upgrades, and new factory implementations in Kenya, Rwanda, Uganda, Somalia, Tanzania, and Ethiopia, as well as locations in western Africa.


Technological Development:

Fuel sources for kilns continues to be an issue of concern, particularly where competition for firewood for other basic needs is acute. In a continued effort with Howell’s Railway Products of the UK and input from various international factories a briquetting machine is being developed to replace the use of wood with compressed pellets made from sawdust and other agricultural by-products.

In the first stages of factory implementation manually operated hydraulic filter presses are often used to begin modest production of 30-100 filters per day. These presses have undergone an incredible process of evolution as local knowledge, materials and skills have been used to apply basic design principals in locally appropriate ways. Because of this, their development has progressed in an uncoordinated way with widely variable results. In an effort to improve the basic filter press design, Potters Without Borders and the International Joint Filter Committee have begun a survey of filter press design and usage, with over 20 international factories participating.

Recognizing a raw clay source as appropriate for the production of filters is an important aspect of feasibility and development stages of filter production. Working on the hypothesis that these qualities are directly related to particle size distribution, we have begun a program of testing clays from various international factories to develop an appropriate method of field analysis. It is hoped that using this data, clays from unreliable sources can be blended to produce a more consistent product.

 

I’ve been impressed by all that we’ve been able to accomplish and excited about the possibilities.  I encourage you to find out more.  Or if you have the feeling, as I do, that this is a worthwhile effort, consider making a donation, or getting more involved, by becoming a member, becoming a volunteer, or all of the above.

If you think this is worthwhile and want to help:

Donate (Online or by snail-mail)
Become A Member ($20) – Volunteer!
Join The Mailing List – E-mails about projects

Thanks for reading!

 

CBC.ca | Daybreak South

CBC.ca | Daybreak South.

Interviews: Daybreak South, CBC Radio, July 27 2011
Potters Without Borders – Burt Cohen speaks with Marion Barschel

Potters Without Borders has been working for years to bring clean water to African homes. Burt Cohen of Enderby is the executive director of Potters Without Borders. These are some photos he took while in Somaliland last November.

Read more on CBC.ca | Daybreak South…

CBC.ca | Daybreak South.

Interviews: Daybreak South, CBC Radio, July 27 2011
Potters Without Borders – Burt Cohen speaks with Marion Barschel

Potters Without Borders has been working for years to bring clean water to African homes. Burt Cohen of Enderby is the executive director of Potters Without Borders. These are some photos he took while in Somaliland last November.

Thumbnail image for PottersA.JPGFlow testing filters at the Biyo Miireceramic water filter factory in Hargeisa, Somaliland. This factory was set up in early 2010 by the Red Crescent Society and is currently responding to the increased demand caused by the large number of displaced people in the region.

Daybreak’s Marion Barschel spoke with Burt Cohen about what this organization is doing in Africa right now.

Sustainable Colloidal-Silver-Impregnated Ceramic Filter for Point-of-Use Water Treatment

Environ. Sci. Technol. 2008, 42, 927–933
V I N K A A . O Y A N E D E L – C R A V E R A N D
J A M E S A . S M I T H *
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering,
University of Virginia, P.O. Box 400742,
Charlottesville, Virginia 22904-4742

 

Cylindrical colloidal-silver-impregnated ceramic filters for household (point-of-use) water treatment were manufactured
and tested for performance in the laboratory with respect to flow rate and bacteria transport.

http://potterswithoutborders.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/oyanedel-craver-and-smith-est-2008.pdf

Effectiveness of Ceramic Filteration for Drinking Water Treatment in Cambodia

Joseph Mark Brown
A dissertation submitted to the faculty of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the
Department of Environmental Sciences and Engineering.

Chapel Hill 2007

 

ABSTRACT
JOSEPH MARK BROWN: EFFECTIVENESS OF CERAMIC FILTRATION FOR
DRINKING WATER TREATMENT IN CAMBODIA
(Under the direction of Mark D. Sobsey, Ph.D.)
For the estimated 66% of Cambodians without access to improved drinking water sources and the potentially much greater percentage without consistent access to microbiologically safe water, point-of-use water treatment coupled with appropriate storage to prevent recontamination is a promising option for securing access to safe drinking water. The ceramic water purifier (CWP) is an emerging point-of-use water treatment technology that is made locally in Cambodia and in several other developing countries based on a design originally developed in Latin America in the 1980s. Despite the filter’s increasingly widespread promotion and implementation as a public health intervention within Cambodia and worldwide, its effectiveness in reducing waterborne microbes and diarrheal disease in users has not been adequately characterized. This dissertation examines: (i) the microbiological effectiveness of locally produced ceramic filters in Cambodia against bacterial and viral surrogates in the laboratory and in field use; (ii) the health impacts of the CWP and a modified CWP in a randomized, controlled trial in a rural/peri-urban village; and (iii) the continued use, microbiological effectiveness, and sustained health impacts of the CWP after up to 44 months in household use in three provinces of Cambodia.

http://potterswithoutborders.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/joe-brown-dissertation.pdf

A Review of Current Implementation Practices

Household Water Treatment and Safe Storage Options in Developing Countries:
A Review of Current Implementation Practices
By Daniele S. Lantagne, Robert Quick, and Eric D. Mintz1
U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

Note: This draft paper was commissioned the Navigating Peace Initiative, a project launched by the Woodrow Wilson International Center for ScholarsÂ’ Environmental Change and Security Program and funded by the Carnegie Corporation of New York. For more information, please visit www.wilsoncenter.org/water.

http://potterswithoutborders.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/household_water_treatment.pdf

Conclusion
HWTS systems are proven, low-cost interventions that have the potential to provide safe water to those who will not have access to safe water sources in the near term, and thus significantly reduce morbidity due to waterborne diseases and improve the quality of life. HWTS implementations have developed from small pilot projects to national-scale programs, and now face questions on how to reach the more than 1.1 billion in need of safe drinking water, and how to effectively work with other water, sanitation, and hygiene programs to achieve the greatest health impact. The active, diverse, and expanding community of researchers, private companies, faith-based organizations, international and local NGOs, and donors interested in answering these questions can play a major role in helping the world achieve the Millennium Development Goal to halve, by 2015, the proportion of people without access to safe water (World Bank Group, 2004). To achieve this goal, and to surpass it, will require continued collaboration, research and development, and investment, but it is our best hope for rapidly reducing the burden of waterborne disease and death in developing countries.

Ceramic silver impregnated pot filters for household drinking water treatment in developing countries

Master of Science Thesis in Civil Engineering
Sanitary Engineering Section
Department of Water Management
Faculty of Civil Engineering
Delft University of Technology
Doris van Halem
November 2006

 

Introduction
The World Health Organization (WHO)/UNICEF assessed in 2000 that 1.1 billion people do not have access to ‘improved drinking-water sources’. Interventions in hygiene, sanitation and water supply make proven contributors to controlling this disease burden. The ambitious target established in the ‘Millennium Development Goal1’ (MDG # 7) is “halving the proportion of people without sustainable access to safe water and basic sanitation by 2015”. Providing
more than half a billion people with safe drinking water is a major task, especially because most of them are living in rural areas. Despite major efforts to deliver safe, piped, community water to the worldÂ’s population, the reality is that water supplies delivering safe water will not be available to these people on such a short term. According to the WHO a short-term solution to meet the basic need of safe drinking water can be found in household water treatment and safe storage (HWTS).

http://potterswithoutborders.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/finalcsfreport_29-10-2-van-dalem1.pdf

Study on Life Span of Ceramic Filter Colloidal Silver Pot Shaped (CSP) Model

Presented to :
Potters for Peace
August – 2005
Enrique Campbell, Consultant
Managua, Nicaragua

 

Introduction
Several studies on the ceramic filter promoted by Potters for Peace have been carried out previously. Nevertheless, since the CSP model started to be distributed it has not been defined for how much time the filter can removes bacteria and parasites effectively. An approach on this issue was conducted in 1999 by the Aquatic Resources Research Center (CIRA, in Spanish) of the Nicaragua National University (UNAN) along a research work on the CSP model. For that study a seven years old filtering element was tested for total coliform, fecal coliform an fecal streptococcus removal. The esults obtained showed that the CSP was capable of removing all the total coliform and fecal coliform organism, but also increase slightly the concentration of fecal streptococcus (see more details in Lantagne 2001). It should noted that the seven years old filtering element that was used for the test was one of the first prototypes, and it was a little bit smaller than those that exist and are distributed today which is why the mentioned results couldnÂ’t be taken as conclusive for the new type of CSP model.

http://potterswithoutborders.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/filter-longevity-study.pdf

Hydraulic Properties Investigation of the Potters For Peace Colloidal Silver Impregnated Ceramic Filter

Univ-of-col-hydraulic-properties-study.pdf

Exec-summary-univ-of-col-study.pdf

Christopher J. Fahlin
Undergraduate Independent Study Research
University of Colorado at Boulder
College of Engineering
Advising Professor: Dr. Angela Bielefeldt
March 7, 2003

 

Abstract
This study investigated the hydraulic properties of the Potters For Peace filter in greater detail than previous studies by Sten Eriksen and Daniele Lantagne. Hydraulic properties such as the hydraulic conductivity and tortuosity are important because they help determine the contact time of pathogens in the water with silver to provide inactivation. Two laboratory tests were conducted using both experimental and numerical methods for attaining the results. Unfortunately, the hydraulic conductivity results were questionable for many reasons and the tortuosity results varied considerably due to the porosity variability results. This research does not conclusively describe the hydraulic properties for the PFP ceramic filter, but it does have model improvements and many recommendations for future research. Future work resulting from this research will hopefully lead to accurate and conclusive results about the hydraulic properties of this economically feasible and effective filter.

Keywords
Engineers Without Borders, Potters For Peace, Filtrón, Appropriate technology, ceramic filter, colloidal
silver, developing countries, drinking water, point-of-use treatment.

Ceramic Water Purifier Cambodia Field Tests

Cwp-cambodia-field-tests-2003-10.pdf
IDE Working Paper No. 1
October 2003
Michael Roberts, M.S.
International Development Enterprises

 

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This report summarizes results from a year-long pilot project in Cambodia to test the Ceramic Water Purifier, a low-cost household water treatment technology that removes microbiological contamination at the point of use. The pilot project was conducted by International Development Enterprises (IDE) with financial assistance from the Health and Nutrition Initiatives Fund supported by the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA).

The Ceramic Water Purifier (CWP) consists of a porous, pot-shaped filter element made of kiln-fired clay and impregnated with colloidal silver. The ceramic filter element is set in a plastic receptacle tank with a lid and a spigot. Raw water is poured into the filter element and seeps through the clay producing potable water at a rate of 2 to 3 litres per hour. The filter element holds approximately 10 litres, allowing a family to produce 20 to 30 litres of water
per day with two to three fillings. Monthly maintenance consists of scrubbing the ceramic filter element to unclog pores and washing the receptacle tank and spigot to prevent bacterial growth. The current cost of the CWP is approximately $7.50 for a complete unit (including manufacturer and retailer profit but not including transportation) and approximately $4.50 for the filter element alone, which needs to be replaced about once every two to three years.

Comparative Analysis of the Filtron and Biosand Water Filters

Comparative_analysis_of_the_fltron_and_biosand_water_filterseditms.pdf
William F. Duke, MD,1* Rick Nordin2 and Asit Mazumder2

1University of Victoria, Restoration of Natural Systems Program , Victoria, British Columbia,
2University of Victoria, Department of Biology, P.O. Box 3020 STN CSC, Victoria, British Columbia

* Corresponding author;

 

Abstract
For many of the 1.1 billion people who now lack access to safe water, affordable water filters designed for use in individual households provide a practical alternative to municipal water treatment systems. Two of the most commonly promoted filters in developing countries are the Filtron ceramic filter and the BioSand intermittent slow sand filter.

To compare the performance of these two filters, pond water was put through each filter for 30 consecutive days. Turbidity, TOC, DOC, E. coli and total coliform counts were recorded daily for the source water and for the filtered water from each filter. Flow rates and frequency of cleaning were also recorded for each filter. Both filters lowered the turbidity, TOC, DOC, and bacterial counts significantly.

The Filtron filter was more effective in removing bacteria, but it was limited by flow rates of only 1-2 liters per hour as well as the need for frequent cleaning. The biosand filter produced flow rates of about 20 liters per hour and did not require cleaning during the study period, but it was less effective in removing bacteria.

Colloidal Silver – Briefing

Colloidal-silver.pdf
Colloids are submicroscopic particles of material suspended in a liquid. Silver is converted to colloidal
silver by running a positive electrical current through bars of pure silver suspended in water. The size of
colloidal silver particles is generally between .015 – .005 microns. Upon becoming a colloid, silver takes
on a positive ionic charge.

The mechanism by which silver accomplished the disinfection of bacteria was first termed �oligodynamic�
referring to the fact that it�s qualities may be observed even when present only in extremely limited
quantities. Silver reacts strongly with thiol (sulphydryl, SH) groups in both functional and structural
proteins of the bacterial cell. Research indicates that silver inhibits glucose, succinate, and lactate
oxidation (dehydrogenation), possibly by means of an uncoupling effect. Zimmerman (1952) had already
demonstrated that low concentrations of silver do not enter the cell. Rather, they are adsorbed onto the
bacterial surface just as silver tends to adsorb to other surfaces thus silver ions immobilize
dehydrogenation because respiration occurs across the cell membrane in bacteria rather than across the
mitochondrial membrane as in eukaryotic cells.

Prior to 1938, when patentable antibacterial drugs began to be developed, colloidal silver was a
mainstream antibacterial agent in the US. It is still widely used to prevent scumming in water storage
tanks. It is used to sterilize water aboard NASA’s Space Shuttle program. Many airlines companies
routinely use colloidal silver for in-flight water purification. Today interest in colloidal silver as a powerful
home remedy, as well as an effective water purifier, is at an all time high.

Many colloidal silver enthusiasts recommend this material as a safe topical and internal cure-all for a wide
variety of maladies. Some encourage daily ingestion of colloidal silver as a preventative measure. Others
warn consumers of self-interested marketing efforts designed to cash in on whatever the latest personal
health fad might be. Warnings are posted as to possible toxic side effects which could result from the
buildup of silver in the bloodstream.

Potters for Peace takes no position on the claim of colloidal silver’s effectiveness as an antibacterial agent
to be directly ingested in relatively large daily, or regular doses. Our interest is strictly focused on the
historical and well-documented application of colloidal silver as a safe and effective water purification
agent used in conjunction with various filtration and storage methods for both large and small water
systems.

Colloidal silver is not listed as a toxin by the Environmental Protection Agency’s Poison Control Center.
Likewise, the Food and Drug Administration has no regulations regarding the use of colloidal silver as an
antibacterial in any form or method, although due to the recent upsurge of interest in this material, many
believe some sort of guidelines will be forthcoming.

The toxic side effect, mentioned previously, resulting from a buildup of silver in the bloodstream is known
as “Argyreia;” a blueish-grey discoloration of the skin. Medical science recognizes Argyreia as specifically
caused by intensive long-term exposure to silver compounds, such as silver nitrate, silver sulfate, silver
sulfadiazine, etc., not from micro-particles of ionic silver.

The Filtron employs colloidal silver through a one time initial saturation of the filter medium by a .32%
solution in approximately 200 grams of water. See Test Request for application details. It is highly
recommended that the filter medium be periodically cleaned (at least annually in case of high turbidity
levels in the source water) and re-saturated with colloidal silver. On-going studies are focused on
determining a more or less exact timetable of filter medium renewal, but the longest (albeit unscientific)
study yet indicates that after 15 years the filter is still doing it’s job.

Although the total amount of colloidal silver used in the Filtron is relatively minute, it is still
possible that even smaller trace quantities of the material could pass directly into the filtered
water. To date, no medical study conducted on colloidal silver has indicated that it poses a
threat to human health. In his “Case Study of 30 Years of Use with Silver Disinfected Drinking
Water” (1983), Michael Owen states that “Colloidal silver does not appear to be readily
absorbed by the human body. Excess silver deposited in the stomach is precipitated as silver
chloride by the stomach bile, and almost immediately excreted through the feces.”

For a more detailed description of the properties of colloidal silver, refer to the following
documents;”A Closer Look At Colloidal Silver,” by Peter A. Lindemann, and “A Brief History of
ColloidalSilver,” by Dr. Gary Smith; �Antimicrobial Activity and Action of Silver�, Progress in
Medicinial Chemistry, Hugo Russel, Elsevier Science B.V. Vol 31, 1994; Drinking Water and
Health, Vol. 2 National Academy Press, Washington D.C. 1980.